London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal has dismissed a £2 billion class action against Sony over the prices it charges on the PlayStation Store, ending a claim brought on behalf of roughly 12.2 million UK console owners. The judgment, issued on 17 November 2026, means no payout will be made and leaves Sony’s digital storefront closed to rival sellers for now.
The case was filed in August 2022 by consumer campaigner Alex Neill. It alleged that Sony’s 30% cut on game sales pushed digital games to “excessive and unfair” prices and that Sony had built a “closed ecosystem” which made players an “entirely captive class.” The claimants argued that digital content would have been about 20% cheaper without those practices, and sought around £1.49 billion in damages plus 8% annual interest, a total of about £1.97 billion.
For PlayStation owners hoping for a refund, the answer is no. The tribunal found that the class representative had “failed to establish that Sony has infringed competition law.” It said the market definitions used in the claim were “unsafe” and that the claim that players were trapped was “not credible.”
How the tribunal reached its decision
The panel, chaired by Ben Tidswell with Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard, ruled that Sony competes in a wider market alongside Xbox, Nintendo and PC, not merely against other PlayStation sellers. It found “strong evidence of a willingness of consumers to switch consoles following an increase in games prices,” citing Sony research that forecast commercial harm if PlayStation game prices were uncompetitive with Xbox.
The tribunal also accepted that shoppers could buy physical games instead of digital copies, and that making PlayStation support third-party stores would carry heavy costs and could weaken security and performance. It noted that Sony sells consoles at low or negative profitability and recovers its money later through games, add-on content and services.
The trial ran for ten weeks between March and May, and Sony called 12 factual witnesses. The claim covers about 12.2 million UK consumers who bought digital content on PlayStation consoles. The Competition and Markets Authority intervened in the case, filing written observations on points of law.
Will PlayStation users get a refund? Not from this case. The tribunal dismissed the claim in its entirety, so no compensation will be paid. The ruling also makes it harder for future suits to force platform holders to open their consoles to competing stores.
The case is the latest test of how far competition law can reach into closed digital stores. In 2025 the same tribunal found that Apple had abused its dominant position by steering users through the App Store and its 30% commission, and Apple later relaxed its policies to allow alternative web stores. The Sony claim failed where the Apple claim succeeded because the panel accepted that console buyers had real alternatives.
Sony is phasing out physical discs for new PlayStation games from January 2028, which will remove one of the alternatives the tribunal relied on. Similar claims are still alive elsewhere, including a Dutch case over the so-called “Sony tax” that covers more than 20,000 participants.



